National Reciprocity Passes House, What Now?
(22 November 2011) On November 16 the US House passed H.R.822, the National Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act. This legislation basically says that any state that issues concealed firearms permits must honor the permits issued by other states, much as states honor each other’s driver’s licenses. While language in the bill includes citation of the Commerce Clause of the Constitution for authority, the stronger argument lies in the Constitution’s call for “full faith and credit” regarding contracts and legal issues across state lines. The bill is now awaiting action in the Senate where it is likely to be referred to a committee and, in all likelihood be left to languish without a hearing or a vote until Congress adjourns.
This bill is an excellent example of something I discussed in a column a few weeks ago — the way politicians play political games with hot-button legislation. In this case the legislation was being pushed pretty hard by Republican leaders in the House looking to make points with GunVoters and to put Democrats in a bind. The whole thing was probably just so much kabuki theatre — an elaborately staged drama to arrive at a predetermined outcome. There is little chance of the bill making it through the Democrat-controlled Senate and of getting past the President’s veto pen. For most House members the vote was an easy call. It was supported by the Republican leadership and was almost certainly going to pass, so the only question was how their vote would play for the folks back home. Most members are smart enough to realize that GunVoters vote in large numbers based on politicians’ actions while the anti-rights crowd simply doesn’t have any kind of strong voter base.